Monday, October 09, 2006

 

Lessons from Portland, Maine

Recently, I was in Maine on business and had a couple of hours to kill before my flight, so I made my first visit into Downtown Portland. Portland's downtown was smaller than I had imagined, yet still nicely urban in a comfortable, unpretentious way. There was a solid foundation of well-maintained historic commercial, residential, and civic buildings, interspersed by a few contemporary structures, some blighted properties, and an occasional parking lot. Overall, the downtown area was definitely more intact and pleasant than not, yet it still left an impression that it had seen livelier days. But while some blocks were rather sketchy, there was also clear evidence of building renovations, conversions and investment taking place in the area, and a general feeling that things there were getting better, not worse. Here are a few general street photos, taken at about 11:30 AM on a weekday:



Then, after deciding to explore just a bit farther down Congress Street, I stumbled upon Monument Square, a small, civic plaza surrounded by buildings and featuring a large war memorial statue. From a block away, it didn't appear as the city's most engaging urban space, yet as I entered the plaza, I found it to be exactly that. Here's a shot of Monument Square as seen from across the street and from high above (thanks to GoogleEarth):


The square hosts a small farmers market one day a week, and I was lucky enough to be there on the right day. The presence of the farmers market, consisting of only about a half-dozen or so booths in a rather small area, completely invigorated the area. The several small restaurants that inhabit the ground floor of the adjacent buildings--their outdoor seating areas spilling out onto the square--were buzzing with activity. The square itself was alive with people of all types, from elementary school children on a field trip to see how many different fruits and vegetables they could identify, to seniors citizens, local residents walking their dogs, downtown workers on their lunch hour, skateboarding teens, and a few camera-wielding visitors (like me).

The place was amazing and authentic. It wasn't canned urbanism, nor was it an elaborate programmed production target-marketed at an upscale demographic. There was no gimmick. It was simply a very modest farmers market held in an intimate urban space, and yet it was tremendous.

So I began thinking... why don't we have something like this in Denver? Where would the intimate "Monument Square" place be in Denver that could host a small farmers market? Actually, we do have a farmers market now in Downtown. This summer, thanks to the Civic Center Conservancy, a farmers market was regularly held in the center plaza at Civic Center Park. While I applaud the Conservancy's efforts to bring activity to Civic Center Park, I wouldn't exactly describe the center of the park as particularly intimate, nor is it bordered by restaurants or retail that can contribute to the vitality.

For several years now, Cherry Creek has hosted a regular farmers market. But, the location? A big parking lot at the corner of a busy intersection. So much for a cozy location or having the synergistic influences of adjacent restaurant patios or retail storefronts.

If I had to pick a place for a small farmers market in Downtown Denver that has similar qualities to Portland's Monument Square, I'd suggest Writer's Square, the plaza in front of RTD's Market Street Station, or Skyline Park. All three of these spaces are generally underutilized, are relatively small in area, and have restaurants or retail nearby. Imagine, in any of these three spaces, a small cluster of vendors selling fresh fruits, vegetables, and flowers a day or two a week during the summer and fall, and how it would contribute to the energy of Downtown Denver.

Sometimes we can over-complicate downtown revitalization. A modest farmers market in the right location or a couple of designated "busker" corners can go a long way in enhancing our Downtown environment.


Comments:
I really like the farmers market idea, but you are exactly right that there isn't enough supporting elements to make civic centers the 'grandest'. As far has great intimate farmers markets, Denver has several. South Pearl's probably my favorite, feels like small town USA. East High's has a nice urban dynamic because of the new devts on Colfax and the East High Esplande and possibilities of a great walk or bike through City Park to get to it.
I think its a good comparison of civic center to a grand square or piazza. One element that would really help things would at least more native stone rather than so much white concrete. I also don't think its necessary to keep as much lawn, most of the great plazas all over the world often have no lawn, instead rely on urban dynamics and injections of color.
 
Very astute observations, I agree with your conclusions on the Civic Center Farmers Market AND the ridiculous spot chosen for the Cherry Creek Market. I must say tho, the Cherry Creek one does attract quite a crowd but it's location in a Bed Bath & Beyond parking lot is atrocious.

You know I was thinking that in your Elitch's plan that the grand plaza you've envisioned would be perfect for a market of sorts.

And not every public monument has to be a water feature, we could use a good tall beaming statue in a grand plaza surrounded by ground floor cafe's. Not to say that we should copy Portland, but we definitely lack intimate public spaces like some of those found back east.

But for now, we are still celebrating our Art Museum opening and next year we get another one in the CPV! YAY!
 
I seem to remember that years ago there WAS a farmer's market at Market Street Station--some time back in the 1980s or early 1990s. Why there isn't one there now, with all of the nearby residential that has been developed since then, I can't imagine. Another good spot: the plaza between the Millennium Bridge and Little Raven.
 
Back in the early 90's they had a farmers market down at Market St station. That was cool, even with the low amount of people that were living downtown at the time.

Why not use the recently renovated Skyline Park?
 
Don't forget the South Pearl Street farmers market on Sunday mornings. Definitely not a busy corner in Cherry Creek.
 
outside of an urban setting but still in proxemics of denver proper you can find a monopoly on the flax seed industry at the old south pearl street farmer's market.

and downtown, there used to be great organic produce at the ballpark market across from coors' field, but that too was in a parking lot and featured mostly used cowboy boots and rocking chairs.

you're very right, though; for a city and state that boasts such an emphasis on produce, you'd think markets would be more accessible.
 
Stapleton has a farmers market in the little area surrounded by restaurants and that might be the best setting in Denver. There was an attempt to have one on Park Avenue but the attendance did not justify the fees charged by the organizers. And the one in Civic Park is a joke. The vendors need to have the foot traffic that will support several dozen businesses.
I would hope that if the towers are constructed on Lawrence, then there could be a market in the Skyline Park, and that the Tabor businesses would benefit. That park would be great because it is mostly hard surfaces that would support booths without destroying the grass.
 
Glad you enjoyed Portland on your visit! Maybe I can make it out to Denver someday. Keep up the good blogging!
 
Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?